What Went Right? The Kiwis were not going to be taken out of their game plan. They stayed compact, disciplined and very well organized both in possession and in defense, and they never wavered no matter what the score or what their opponents did. Made effective use of long passes and got into the final third and kept teams nervous with their long shots on goal. Made their living on defensive mistakes and mental errors. One of the five or six best defenses in the tournament, their defense was aggressive and physical and never lost its shape. Made their opponents work for every single inch of ground. Nobody was able to get into their penalty area with ease or any regularity, so opposition attacks amounted to long-range shots. Gave up a lot of possession but that was by design; they wanted their opponents to come forward in numbers and feel a false sense of defensive security before hitting them on the break. Were surprisingly good at set pieces and 50-50 balls, and were really great at defending against them.
What Went Wrong? They just didn’t have the attacking chops. Their attack was predicated entirely on defensive mistakes and mental errors. If they had had just a modicum of a sustained attack they probably could have stolen a win somewhere and gotten to the next round.
Who Stepped Up To The Plate? I’d take their backline of Winston Reid, Ryan Nelson, Tommy Smith and Ivan Vicelich any day of the week and twice on Sunday. Simon Elliott and Tony Lochhead were stellar interrupting the opposition attack in the midfield. Leo Bertos and Rory Fallon were just suffocating on the flanks. Shane Smeltz actually showed some finishing chops roaming behind the target man Chris Killen. The front four had to spend most of their time defending but they did a good job of patiently waiting for the opposition to make a mistake, and they pounced well.
Who Didn’t Show Up? Nobody, really. Everybody pretty much executed what amounted to a very limited game plan. Clearly the idea was to survive and wait for an opposition mistake.
How Was The Coaching? I’m going to give it an A. Ricki Herbert was a center defender the last time New Zealand made it to the World Cup in 1982. Gee, what gave it away?! His only experience coaching being local, he was smart enough to realize his side didn’t have any star-quality players and weren’t going to beat anybody attacking them. So he employed the most tactically rigid and suffocating system in this tournament and made sure his players never EVER wavered from it, extolling the total team concept. It wasn’t pretty but it did get results.
Did They Finish Where They Were Expected? Well, the Kiwis didn’t get to the next round, but they did finish undefeated and actually earned their chance at progression, as opposed to some sides that just backed into it. If you sat through that game with Paraguay you got plenty of sleep. That said, most of us thought they wouldn’t get a point. Not only did they get three points but they left this tournament undefeated, a feat unto itself, and got themselves into a position to actually advance without backing into it or relying on help from anybody else, exceeding all expectations. Having to qualify from an Oceanic region that consists of football powerhouses Fiji, Samoa, New Caledonia, and Tahiti (sarcasm intended), most people thought New Zealand really didn’t belong here. The Kiwis proved otherwise. MADD, MADD, MADD, MADD, MADD PROPS!!! This is what the World Cup is all about.
Now What? Keep this coach and keep that tactical discipline, but think about getting forward with a little more of a sustained attack. You might just get that one goal you need deliberately next time.